Otterbein United Methodist Church
5009 East 21st St, indianapolis, IN 46218
About Otterbein United Methodist Church
Otterbein United Methodist Church is located on East 21st Street on the east side of Indianapolis, serving the surrounding residential neighborhoods. As a United Methodist congregation, the church is part of a denomination with roots extending back to the Methodist movement of the 18th century, emphasizing personal faith and social responsibility. The church offers multiple opportunities for spiritual growth and community engagement across age groups. Sunday School provides religious education for members and visitors. The United Methodist Women's group organizes service projects and fellowship activities. A Youth Group engages younger members in faith formation and community service. The Handbell Choir performs music during services and events. Small Groups meet throughout the week for Bible study, prayer, and discussion, allowing members to deepen their faith in intimate settings. Otterbein UMC is located at 5009 East 21st Street and welcomes all who wish to attend. The church is wheelchair accessible and provides parking for visitors. Families with young children benefit from the on-site nursery during services. Air conditioning ensures comfort year-round. Coffee and fellowship time allows the congregation to connect before and after gatherings. For those unable to attend in person, the church offers live-streamed services, making participation accessible to homebound members and those with scheduling constraints. More information is available at the church's website.
About Methodist Churches
Methodist churches trace their roots to John Wesley's 18th-century revival movement within the Church of England. They emphasize God's grace available to all people, personal holiness, and social justice — known as "works of piety and mercy." Worship is typically blended, mixing traditional hymns (including Wesley's own compositions) with newer music. United Methodist congregations, the largest Methodist body in the U.S., are connectional — meaning local churches are linked through a shared structure of districts and conferences. Methodists practice infant baptism and open communion, welcoming all who seek Christ to the Lord's Table.
Plan Your Visit
Get directions →On-site parking is available — no need to hunt for street parking
Children's ministry and nursery run during all services — kids are welcome
Fully wheelchair accessible — contact the church for specific accessibility needs
Can't make it in person? Services are live streamed online
Dress code is casual — come as you are
Check the website for any schedule changes before your visit
Member Reviews
★ 4.7 · 13 Google reviewsMs. B is Blessed & Highly Favored
★★★★★Had donations for the church and several cars were in the parking lot, but no one answered to receive the donation of children's, men's & women's clothing and shoes.
Ana G
★★★★★Well, I don’t know about the church itself, but the thrift store is awesome! Great finds, amazing prices, lovely volunteers!
Sermons Online
Otterbein United Methodist Church publishes sermons on YouTube
Service Times
🔒 Claim this listing to add service times
Programs
Amenities & Accessibility
Environmental Profile
Sustainability features and walkability data for this location
Does this church have green features? Claim this listing to add them.
Frequently Asked Questions
What time does Otterbein United Methodist Church hold services?
Where is Otterbein United Methodist Church located?
5009 East 21st St, indianapolis, IN 46218
What denomination is Otterbein United Methodist Church?
Otterbein United Methodist Church is a Methodist church.
How do I contact Otterbein United Methodist Church?
Call (317) 357-3535 or visit http://www.umc.org/find-a-church/church/55032.
What is Otterbein United Methodist Church known for?
Otterbein United Methodist Church is located on East 21st Street on the east side of Indianapolis, serving the surrounding residential neighborhoods.
Church Health Score
Based on Google rating, reviews, and online presence
Strong
This church scores 79/100 compared to other Methodist churches in indianapolis.
Methodist Benchmarks
Hartford Seminary + ECFA national averages
Nearby Churches
Living Word Baptist Church
Baptist · indianapolis, IN
Iglesia Cristiana Alfa & Omega
Pentecostal · indianapolis, IN
Iglesia Tierra Prometida
Pentecostal · indianapolis, IN
Ritter Avenue Free Methodist Church
Methodist · indianapolis, IN
Indy Metro Church
Nondenominational · indianapolis, IN